High Impedance Differential Protection Calculation

High impedance differential protection calculation is one of the most critical aspects of safeguarding power transformers, generators, and busbars. This type of protection scheme uses a simple yet highly effective approach to detect internal faults by comparing the currents entering and leaving the protected zone.

It uses the principle of Kirchhoff’s Current Law, which states that the sum of incoming and outgoing currents in a node should be zero in the absence of faults. Any difference is a clear indication of an internal fault, which must be quickly isolated to avoid equipment damage or system instability.

To achieve accurate and secure protection, the high impedance differential protection calculation must account for various factors. These include CT mismatches, saturation, system conditions, and relay operating characteristics.

Why Use High Impedance Differential Protection?

High impedance schemes are widely used due to their simplicity and reliability. They are particularly preferred for applications like busbar protection and transformer differential protection. One key reason is their stability under external faults and CT saturation.

They do not trip due to external disturbances or CT mismatches because the impedance limits the current through the relay. Only internal faults produce enough voltage across the relay to activate it.

Principle of High Impedance Differential Protection

The basic idea behind high impedance differential protection calculation is to connect the secondary windings of all current transformers (CTs) in parallel. A high impedance element (typically a relay coil with a stabilizing resistor) is connected across this parallel combination.

Under normal conditions, or during external faults, the CTs produce equal and opposite currents. The resulting differential current is zero or very small. The impedance element ensures that the voltage developed across the relay remains below its operating threshold in these cases.

However, during an internal fault, the CTs on the faulted section produce different currents. This creates a voltage across the high impedance element that exceeds the relay pickup setting, causing it to trip.

Components in High Impedance Protection

To perform an accurate high impedance differential protection calculation, we need to consider all key components in the scheme:

1. Current Transformers (CTs): All CTs must have identical ratios and characteristics. Mismatches can result in false trips.
2. Stabilizing Resistor: This limits the voltage across the CT secondaries during external faults.
3. Metrosil (Non-linear Resistor): It protects the relay and CTs from high voltages due to CT saturation.
4. High Impedance Relay: The actual element that detects and trips on fault conditions.

Steps in High Impedance Differential Protection Calculation

Let us now walk through the detailed steps involved in the high impedance differential protection calculation process. Each step plays a vital role in ensuring both security and sensitivity of the scheme.

Step 1: Calculate Maximum Through Fault Current

First, determine the highest external fault current that can flow through the system. This is known as the through fault current and is typically calculated at the point closest to the CT location.

This current will be used to size the stabilizing resistor and ensure the relay does not operate during external faults.

Step 2: Determine CT Secondary Resistance

Measure or obtain the resistance of each CT secondary winding. If not available, estimate using the wire type and length. Typical CT secondary resistance values range from 0.1 to 1 ohm depending on design.

Step 3: Cable Resistance Between CTs and Relay

Include the resistance of the cables used to connect CTs to the relay. This is essential for accurate total loop resistance estimation. Long cable runs can contribute significant resistance.

Step 4: Calculate Total Loop Resistance

Now add all resistances:

• CT secondary resistance (of worst-case CT)
• Cable resistance (both directions)
• Relay coil resistance (often provided in relay manual)

Let’s denote this as:

R_total = R_CT + 2 × R_cable + R_relay

Step 5: Choose Stabilizing Resistor

The stabilizing resistor ensures the relay does not operate during external faults. It drops sufficient voltage across the relay terminals to prevent unwanted operation.

It is calculated using the formula:

R_stab = (V_min / I_through) – R_total

Where:

• V_min is the relay pickup voltage (usually 20–100V)
• I_through is the maximum through fault current (in secondary amperes)

Choose a resistor slightly higher than the calculated value to ensure safety margins.

Step 6: Metrosil Selection

To prevent damage from high voltages during CT saturation, a Metrosil (or similar device) is added. It clamps the voltage below the insulation level of CTs and cables.

Metrosil selection depends on:

• Maximum fault voltage
• Time duration of overvoltage
• Relay and CT insulation rating

Step 7: Relay Pickup Setting

Finally, the pickup setting of the high impedance relay must be chosen. It should be:

• Higher than the voltage produced during CT saturation or external faults
• Lower than the voltage developed during minimum internal faults

Use safety factors to ensure dependable operation.

Example of High Impedance Differential Protection Calculation

Let us now take a simple example to illustrate the high impedance differential protection calculation:

Assume:

• CT secondary current: 1 A
• Maximum through fault current: 25 A
• CT resistance: 0.3 ohm
• Cable resistance: 0.2 ohm (one way)
• Relay coil resistance: 0.1 ohm
• Relay pickup voltage: 50 V

Step-by-step:

1. R_total = 0.3 + (2 × 0.2) + 0.1 = 0.8 ohm
2. R_stab = (50 / 25) – 0.8 = 2 – 0.8 = 1.2 ohm

So, select a stabilizing resistor of 1.2 ohms or higher.

3. Metrosil to clamp voltage < 200 V, depending on insulation.
4. Ensure relay trips at voltages > 50 V (internal fault) and remains stable otherwise.

Applications of High Impedance Differential Protection

This scheme is widely used in:

• Busbar protection: Ensures fast and selective tripping.
• Transformer protection: Offers an additional layer along with percentage differential.
• Generator protection: Prevents winding damage under internal faults.

In such cases, high impedance protection is often coordinated with Differential Relay in Transformer systems.

Advantages of High Impedance Protection

• Simple design and implementation
• High stability during external faults
• Fast operation during internal faults
• No need for complex CT ratio matching

Challenges and Precautions

While reliable, high impedance differential protection calculation must account for:

• CT saturation under high fault conditions
• Ensuring proper grounding and wiring
• Maintaining uniform CT polarity
• Regular testing and maintenance

Additionally, during commissioning, tests like the PI Test of Transformer ensure that insulation and wiring can handle the expected overvoltages.

In systems with multiple transformers, especially star-delta configurations, engineers must understand Fault Current Distribution in Star Delta Transformer networks to place CTs correctly and avoid misoperations.

Impact of CT Saturation

CT saturation can create unequal current waveforms. This can mislead differential protection schemes. In high impedance protection, the use of a stabilizing resistor and Metrosil helps counteract this effect.

Still, care must be taken to select CTs with adequate knee-point voltage. This ensures they remain linear up to the required fault current levels.

In scenarios where saturation cannot be avoided, setting margins and including safety factors in Differential Relay Setting Calculation for Transformer is crucial.

Integration with Modern Protection Systems

Today, digital relays support high impedance modules as part of multifunction protection units. These can be coordinated with:

• Overcurrent and distance protection
• Transformer protection schemes
• Busbar differential protection
• Protection coordination studies using Fault Current at Transformer Secondary

Modern software tools also help simulate faults and optimize the high impedance differential protection calculation before deployment.

Conclusion

High impedance differential protection remains a cornerstone of power system safety. It offers unmatched reliability, simplicity, and speed. However, correct high impedance differential protection calculation is essential for its effectiveness.

By understanding the principles, component roles, and calculations, engineers can implement secure and dependable protection systems. Real-world systems are rarely ideal, so applying safety factors and considering worst-case conditions ensures long-term reliability.

Follow Us on Social:

• LinkedIn
• Facebook
• Pinterest
• Threads
• X

Subscribe our Newsletter on Electrical Insights to get the latest updates in Electrical Engineering.

#HighImpedanceProtection, #DifferentialRelay, #TransformerProtection, #ElectricalEngineering, #RelaySetting, #ImpedanceProtection, #PowerSystemProtection, #ProtectionRelay, #HighImpedanceRelay, #FaultCurrent, #TransformerFault, #ProtectionCalculation, #SubstationProtection, #StarDeltaTransformer, #ElectricalSafety